Murder and Misdirection

“Fui bailar no meu batel além do mar cruel,” sings fadista Dulce Pontes in this movie’s dramatic title song Canção do Mar: “I went dancing in my little boat, beyond the cruel sea.” And it must be just like a nutshell-sized boat dancing on a stormy ocean’s waves that nineteen-year-old Aaron Stampler (Edward Norton) feels after his arrest for the savage murder of Chicago’s saintly Archbishop Rushman. Or does it?

Certainly it doesn’t help that Aaron was caught running from the crime scene, covered in blood, and with the archbishop’s ring in his pocket. Besides, who is going to believe him anyway – a stuttering, uneducated boy from rural Kentucky who was found begging by the powerful clergyman, taken in as an altar boy and made to sing in his choir – that he was present when the murder was committed but can’t remember a single thing because he blacked out? Nobody; surely not the police and ADA Janet Venable (Laura Linney), assigned by D.A. / Rushman friend Shaughnessy (John Mahoney) personally to try the case, with the express mandate to obtain a death penalty conviction. Nobody, that is, except Aaron’s defense attorney Martin Vail (Richard Gere). Vail, of all people: the flamboyant ADA-turned-private-practitioner, the star attorney not shying away from even the shadiest client, to whom TV and magazine cover interviews are as second nature as his courtroom appearances, and who cynically quotes as his mottos a professor’s maxims on his first day in law school: “From this day forward, if your mother says she loves you, get a second opinion.” And: “If you want justice, go to a whorehouse. If you want to get fucked, go to court.”

Primal Fear was adapted from William Diehl‘s like-named bestselling novel and, like in many literary adaptations, its screenplay is a hit-and-miss affair. Not successful, in my view, are those alterations that unnecessarily make Vail an even more ethically questionable lawyer as already conceived by Diehl; such as the way he becomes Stampler’s attorney in the first place (which in the movie amounts to blatant client solicitation, not to mention that no sane lawyer would introduce himself to a potential client with the words “I’m what you call a ‘big shot’ attorney”), and the circumstances surrounding the discovery of a tape revealing the archbishop’s not-so-nice private side, which in the novel isn’t found by Vail but by his investigator Tommy Goodman (Andre Braugher): of course that doesn’t eliminate Vail’s ultimate ethical responsibility, but contrarily to the movie, at least he doesn’t “borrow” the tape from the crime scene himself, and he doesn’t know in advance what Tommy is up to. Further, in the book the tape is not shown in open court and immediately introduced into evidence but viewed in the presence of only the judge and the attorneys, which given its contents seems more realistic; even if it were later introduced into evidence after all. On the other hand, particularly regarding the main characters the movie’s alterations work well: Unethical or not, Richard Gere’s Martin Vail is even more interesting than the character devised by Diehl; moreover, an unnecessarily clichéd, ultraconservative judge nicknamed “Hangin'” Harry Shoat becomes an – although still tough – overall more multidimensional and human Judge Miriam Shoat (Alfre Woodard).  Similarly, Vail’s mafia-affiliated client Joey Pinero (Steven Bauer) gains considerably in stature; and although it actually reinforces cliché to shift the love/sex relationship from the book’s present one between Vail and psychiatrist Dr. Arrington (Frances McDormand) to the screenplay’s past one between Vail and Venable (which the ADA now derogatorily calls “a one-night-stand [that] lasted six months”), thanks to Gere’s and Linney’s considerable on-screen chemistry their characters’ personal relationship adds sparks and tension to their professional rivalry that also lend greater credibility to the final courtroom scene’s powder-keg explosion.

Outstanding as all of its actors are, however, Primal Fear rises and falls with the performance of Edward Norton, and it is his breathtaking achievement that validates the movie more than anything. Then-newcomer Norton not only had to portray a boy almost a decade younger than himself (which he manages flawlessly) but also an incredibly complex character, sometimes shifting behavioral patterns, accents and manners of speech from one sentence to the next; and he delivers supremely, deservedly garnering an Oscar nomination (which in a year of extremely tight competition he lost to Cuba Gooding Jr. for Jerry Maguire), as well as a Golden Globe and several other awards; together with his roles in People vs. Larry Flynt and Woody Allen’s Everybody Says I Love You playing himself into audience awareness once and for all.

Although Primal Fear is often cited for its final plot twist, anybody who has seen more than that occasional thriller can see its end coming somewhere halfway through the narrative; and I think that’s true for both book and film, although I admit I hadn’t read the novel when I first saw the movie. Moreover, the final twist depends on a feat on the part of Norton’s character that lawyers and psychiatrists alike will find hard to take at face value. Thus, at first viewing this movie’s end may appear a bit of a let-down. But trust me: The story grows on you the more often you watch it, and in my view it actually helps to know the end, because not only does this enable you to see the many nuances you will necessarily miss the first time around; it also frees you to think about the moral issues addressed – the most glaring ones of which, with the sexual abuse scandal that the Catholic Church in over 30 years still hasn’t seemed to be able to shake off, have long since reached real life public awareness worldwide. For those reasons, and for the entire cast’s – first and foremost Edward Norton’s – fine performances, this has long become one of my favorite courtroom thrillers.


“[I believe that] things are not always as they appear, that sometimes facts can be manipulated the way a magician manipulates an audience. He distracts you with this hand, while the other hand does the tricks. It’s called misdirection.”
Primal Fear, preface: from Martin Vail’s summation in a case entitled The State vs. Nicholas Luma.


Production Credits /
Cast and Crew

Production Credits
  • Studio: Paramount (1996)
  • Director: Gregory Hoblit
  • Executive Producer: Howard W. Koch Jr.
  • Producer: Gary Lucchesi
  • Screenplay: Steve Shagan / Ann Biderman
  • Based on a novel by: William Diehl
  • Music: James Newton Howard
  • Cinematography / Director of Photography: Michael Chapman
  • Edward Norton: Aaron Stampler
  • Richard Gere: Martin Vail
  • Laura Linney: Janet Venable
  • Frances McDormand: Dr. Molly Arrington
  • Andre Braugher: Tommy Goodman
  • John Mahoney: John Shaughnessy
  • Alfre Woodard: Judge Miriam Shoat
  • Stanley Anderson: Archbishop Rushman
  • Steven Bauer: Joey Pinero
  • Reg Rogers: Jack Connerman
  • Terry O’Quinn: Bud Yancy
  • Joe Spano: Captain Abel Stenner
  • Tony Plana: Martinez
  • Maura Tierney: Naomi Chance
  • Jon Seda: Alex
  • Kenneth Tigar: Weil


Major Awards and Honors

Golden Globes (1997)
  • Best Supporting Actor: Edward Norton
National society of Film Critics Awards (1996)
  • Best Supporting Actor, 3d Place: Edward Norton
    Also for “Everyone Says I Love You” (1996) and “The People vs. Larry Flynt” (1996).
Los Angeles Film Critics Association Awards (1996)
  • Best Supporting Actor: Edward Norton
    Also for “Everyone Says I Love You” (1996) and “The People vs. Larry Flynt” (1996).
Boston Society of Film Critics Awards (1996)
  • Best Supporting Actor: Edward Norton
    Also for “Everyone Says I Love You” (1996) and “The People vs. Larry Flynt” (1996).
Chicago Film Critics Association Awards (1997)
  • Most Promising Actor: Edward Norton
    Also for “Everyone Says I Love You” (1996) and “The People vs. Larry Flynt” (1996).
ASCAP Awards (1997)
  • Top Box Office Films: James Newton Howard



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Literature Reviews

Adventures in Arda

Note: This was my summer 2022 project — but while I posted the associated project pages here at the time (Middle-earth and its sub-project pages concerning the people and peoples, timeline, geography, etc. of Arda and Middle-earth, see enumeration under the Boromir meme, below), I never got around to also copying this introductory post from […]

Read More
Literature Reviews

Michael J. Sullivan: Riyria

The Riyria Revelations are the fantasy series that brought Michael J. Sullivan instant recognition back in the late 2000s.  Originally published as a series of six installments, they are now available as a set of three books, with each of the three books comprising two volumes of the original format.  As he did with almost […]

Read More
Literature Reviews

Michael J. Sullivan: Legends of the First Empire

Michael J. Sullivan’s Riyria books have been on my TBR for a while, but until I’d read two short stories from the cycle — The Jester and Professional Integrity — I hadn’t been sure whether his writing would be for me.  Then I found out that (much like Tolkien’s Silmarillion, Unfinished Tales, and The History […]

Read More