Jason Goodwin: The Janissary Tree

Festive Tasks Master Update Post HERE

Festive Tasks, Door 18 — Spiritual Practice or Religious Observance: Read a book with a split timeline — one that takes place in the present and one that takes place in the past — or a book where people from different ends of the spiritual spectrum (believers / nonbelievers, people from different religions etc.) come together to jointly overcome a threat or a crisis.


This book had been on my TBR since practically forever, and given that it’s right up my alley (historical mystery — check; interesting location somewhere abroad — check), I still don’t quite understand how I never got around to it before this year. Anyway, I’m glad I finally remedied this … even if, despite thoroughly enjoying the reading experience, I’m not sure I’ll be returning for more books from the series anytime soon; chiefly because I don’t entirely buy into the basic premise positing a eunuch as the ruling Ottoman monarch’s go-to person for secret investigations of all kinds.

That part out of the way, however, there is plenty to enjoy here; Goodwin paints a vibrant image of Ottoman-era / 19th century Istanbul, contrasting and complementing what those of us living in the West know about late 18th / early 19th century Europe: Turkey was, after all, one of the leading military powers of the day; and both the geopolitical and the domestic aspects of the novel (society, court life, etc.) are very well-researched. As the title (guardedly) indicates, the book is based on a real event, the so-called Auspicious Incident: the forced 1826 disbanding of the Ottoman Empire’s centuries-old elite force, the Janissaries, and their subsequent unsuccessful mutiny. Considering that the vast majority of the Janissaries (several 10,000s of them) were either executed for having participated in the mutiny or killed while that mutiny was suppressed, this novel’s further premise (the idea that the surviving Janissaries went underground and conspired to do away with the Sultan) is not a far-fetched one, either.

I just wish Goodwin had refrained from also using the urban legend claiming that Sultan Mahmud II’s mother (Nakşidil Sultan) was actually Aimée du Buc de Rivéry, a distant cousin in law of Napoleon Bonaparte’s first wife Josephine de Beauharnais, who vanished as a young woman and was rumored to have been abducted by Barbary pirates and sold into a harem. This sort of spurious add-on just unnecessarily diminishes the credibility of an otherwise well-researched book — it may have sounded like an interesting story to Goodwin, but he really should have the sense to resist the easy draw of sensationalism.

All told, though, the historical detail is more interesting than the mystery as such; for one thing, Yashim is yet another investigator who somehow manages to be Holmes and Watson rolled into one (with the Watson persona prominently shining through again and again in the most implausible of ways and situations), until we get to the end, where it is not merely Holmes who suddenly emerges triumphantly but he even somehow, even more implausibly — to the point of ridicule — merges personalities with The Little Corporal. Yet, I enjoyed Yashim’s interactions with the diplomats of the day, particularly his friend, the (on occasion, quite literally) derobed ex-ambassador of the just-then-no-longer-existing Kingdom of Poland.

It is the latter friendship, too — plus a rather crucial episode involving the ambassador of the very-much-still-existing Russian Empire — which justifies me in using this book for Spiritual Practice square of Festive Tasks; as in the cooperation of these gentlemen we have a Muslim, a Roman Catholic and (albeit unwittingly) a Russian Orthodox Christian coming together to prevent what could very much have turned into a second “Auspicious Incident” ten years after the first one. Add in the Sultan’s mother (or her fictional incarnation, at any rate), plus a lady with whom Yashim has a bit of a dalliance (yes, eunuchs really still could, in case you’re wondering), and we have two more Christian ladies taking a hand in the affair … and on the Muslim side, we might as well count in the Sultan, who has just enough of an active role as a character in the novel to count as a noticeable factor.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Literature Reviews

Anthony Berkeley: Murder in the Basement

This is middling Berkeley, not as problematic as The Wychford Poisoning Case or The Silk Stockings Murders, but OTOH also a fair way from the (mostly) enjoyable and intelligent writing that are The Poisoned Chocolates Case and Trial and Error. I rather like the setup — a body found by accident in a place where […]

Read More
Literature Reviews

Phoebe Atwood Taylor: The Cape Cod Mystery

The Appointment with Agatha group’s January 2022 side read: my first book by Atwood Taylor (though I’d heard her name before) and almost certainly not my last one. I’m not entirely sold on the main investigator, Asey Mayo; he comes across as rather too mannered and the book might have benefitted if the first person […]

Read More
Literature Reviews

Zora Neale Hurston: Dust Tracks on a Road

Definitely the best book I read during the first week of the new year; the New Yorker pretty much nailed it when calling the book “warm, witty, imaginative” and adding “This is a rich and winning book.” I’d (finally) read Hurston’s Their Eyes Were Watching God last year; having now read her autobiography, I recongnize […]

Read More
%d bloggers like this: